On April 8, 2020, on this Blog, I summarized some widespread doubts about the outcome of the EU tender with which the European Commission selected Black Rock as advisor to define the methods European banks should follow to integrate ESG sustainability requirements into their business (https://ted.europa.eu/udl?uri=TED:NOTICE:165869-2020:TEXT:EN:HTML&src=0)
After five years, the current geopolitical events sadly confirm that those doubts were more than reasonable doubts.
Today’s bad news finds a hyperbolic synthesis in Black Rock’s recent choice to abandon the Net Zero Alliance, confirming a decisive change of perspective.
It is essential to place some questions at the center of the debate:
(a) What credibility can the indications that Black Rock has made available to the EU Commission during its mandate enjoy?
(b) To what extent do Black Rock’s doubts on the ESG path influence the current desire of the EU Commission to simplify the set of rules on sustainable finance, which Black Rock itself should have helped to build?
(c) What credibility can the European legislator enjoy if, a few years after the publication in 2018 of the Action Plan on financing sustainable growth, it finds itself in the position of having to rethink the set of rules that followed the Action Plan?
(d) Should we expect the choices of simplification of the EU ESG framework to be themselves suggested by Black Rock, with or without circumstantial calls for tenders?
It is to be hoped that the frenzy to activate greater military investments, rapidly replacing health investments of a pandemic nature, is not the bitter answer to these and other open questions.




Italiano